Back to Assessments & Documents
IT Service Management Active

Incident Management Maturity Assessment

A comprehensive capability maturity assessment for IT incident management covering 62 questions across 12 capability domains. Evaluates the full incident lifecycle from recording through classification, major incident ma...

Start Assessment

Overview

A comprehensive capability maturity assessment for IT incident management covering 62 questions across 12 capability domains. Evaluates the full incident lifecycle from recording through classification, major incident management, diagnosis, resolution, closure, monitoring, escalation, and user experience. Written for the Incident Manager who needs to answer: are we restoring service fast enough, are we learning from what breaks, and can we prove it to leadership?

Detailed Description

Incident management is the most visible IT process to the business. When it works, services are restored quickly, users are informed, and major incidents are coordinated with precision. When it fails, users are left in the dark, tickets bounce between teams, major incidents become extended outages, and leadership hears about problems from customers rather than from IT.

This assessment evaluates incident management maturity across twelve domains. It starts with governance - is there a standardized process with KPIs and a named owner? It examines recording - are symptoms documented clearly, are CIs linked, is the KEDB checked at first contact? It assesses classification - is routing accurate, is impact objectively assessed, are major incident criteria defined? It evaluates major incident management as a dedicated capability. It checks diagnosis - is knowledge used, are patterns classified? It reviews resolution - is the fix documented, verified, and linked to change management? It measures closure - does the user confirm resolution? It assesses monitoring - are stalled tickets caught proactively? It covers escalation - are thresholds defined and reasons analyzed? And it evaluates user experience - is satisfaction measured and detractors followed up?

The three-dimension scoring reveals a pattern common in incident management: processes documented in a handbook but implemented differently on each shift, or implemented consistently but never measured for whether MTTR is actually improving.

Assessment Details

Audience

Incident Manager, Service Desk Manager, IT Operations Director, Manager on Duty (MoD), ITSM Process Owner. Also valuable for service level managers assessing SLA compliance drivers and for leadership evaluating the effectiveness of the incident response capability.

Purpose

Identifies strengths and gaps across every dimension of incident management - not just whether tickets are logged, but whether they are classified correctly, routed accurately, resolved with knowledge, closed with user confirmation, monitored proactively, and analyzed for trends. Reveals the common failure: organizations that process incidents but do not manage them.

Effort

Initial assessment: 4-5 hours with a cross-functional team (Incident Manager, service desk lead, MoD, resolver group leads, major incident coordinator, SLA manager). Allow 2-3 hours for evidence gathering. Subsequent reassessments: approximately 3 hours.

Cadence

Annually, or immediately following a series of major incidents that exposed process gaps. Supplement with monthly reviews of MTTR, FCR, SLA compliance, and reopen rate KPIs.

Assessment Outline

(12 chapters · 62 questions)
  1. 1

    1 INM Governance and Process Framework

    • 1.1 Process Documentation 1 questions
    • 1.2 Process Standardization 1 questions
    • 1.3 KPI Framework 1 questions
    • 1.4 Process Integration 1 questions
    • 1.5 Process Ownership 1 questions
    • 1.6 Policy Lifecycle 1 questions
  2. 2

    2 Incident Recording and Initial Data

    • 2.1 Incident Initiation 1 questions
    • 2.2 Unique Identification 1 questions
    • 2.3 Symptom Documentation 1 questions
    • 2.4 CI Identification and Linkage 1 questions
    • 2.5 CI Data Validation 1 questions
    • 2.6 KEDB Check at Recording 1 questions
    • 2.7 Mass Incident Check 1 questions
  3. 3

    3 Incident Classification and Prioritization

    • 3.1 Category Classification 1 questions
    • 3.2 Routing Accuracy 1 questions
    • 3.3 Business Impact Assessment 1 questions
    • 3.4 Priority Matrix 1 questions
    • 3.5 Major Incident Criteria 1 questions
    • 3.6 Rejection Handling 1 questions
  4. 4

    4 Major Incident Management

    • 4.1 Major Incident Process 1 questions
    • 4.2 Bridge and Coordination 1 questions
    • 4.3 Stakeholder Communication 1 questions
    • 4.4 Post-Major-Incident Review 1 questions
    • 4.5 Problem Ticket Linkage 1 questions
  5. 5

    5 Incident Analysis and Diagnosis

    • 5.1 Assignment Verification 1 questions
    • 5.2 Knowledge-Assisted Diagnosis 1 questions
    • 5.3 Error Pattern Classification 1 questions
    • 5.4 Request vs Incident Check 1 questions
    • 5.5 Restorability Assessment 1 questions
  6. 6

    6 Incident Resolution and Documentation

    • 6.1 Resolution Documentation 1 questions
    • 6.2 Post-Resolution Verification 1 questions
    • 6.3 Change Linkage 1 questions
    • 6.4 Post-Resolution Reclassification 1 questions
    • 6.5 Data Quality for Analytics 1 questions
  7. 7

    7 Incident Closure and User Confirmation

    • 7.1 User Confirmation 1 questions
    • 7.2 Pre-Closure Quality Check 1 questions
    • 7.3 Closure Codes 1 questions
    • 7.4 Failed Resolution Handling 1 questions
    • 7.5 Problem Ticket Trigger 1 questions
  8. 8

    8 Incident Monitoring and SLA Management

    • 8.1 Active Incident Monitoring 1 questions
    • 8.2 SLA Visibility 1 questions
    • 8.3 Proactive SLA Management 1 questions
    • 8.4 Trend Analysis 1 questions
    • 8.5 Status Reporting 1 questions
    • 8.6 Security Incident Handling 1 questions
  9. 9

    9 Escalation Management

    • 9.1 Escalation Function 1 questions
    • 9.2 Escalation Thresholds 1 questions
    • 9.3 Escalation Communication 1 questions
    • 9.4 Escalation Tracking 1 questions
    • 9.5 Escalation Analysis 1 questions
  10. 10

    10 User Experience and Communication

    • 10.1 Single Point of Contact 1 questions
    • 10.2 Post-Resolution Satisfaction 1 questions
    • 10.3 Detractor Follow-Up 1 questions
    • 10.4 Proactive User Updates 1 questions
  11. 11

    11 People, Roles and Capability

    • 11.1 Role Definitions 1 questions
    • 11.2 Role Staffing 1 questions
    • 11.3 RACI Matrix 1 questions
    • 11.4 Training and Skills 1 questions
  12. 12

    12 Measurement, Reporting and Improvement

    • 12.1 KPI Tracking 1 questions
    • 12.2 Business Impact Measurement 1 questions
    • 12.3 Improvement Register 1 questions
    • 12.4 Maturity Self-Assessment 1 questions

At a Glance

Category IT Service Management
Type Free
Chapters 12
Questions 62
Start Assessment

Still have questions? Get in touch

ITSGovernance
  • Twitter

Contact us

ITSGovernance